Smart Transport

Police commissioner calls for ban on smart motorways

Busy motorway

A South Yorkshire police crime commissioner (PCC) has written to Transport Secretary Grant Shapps calling for a ban on smart motorways.

In an open letter to the Government, Dr Alan Billings, urged the Government to ‘abandon’ smart motorways – where all lanes are live such as that along the M1 in South Yorkshire, and labelled them “inherently unsafe and dangerous”.

Billings said: “I believe smart motorways of this kind - where what would be a hard shoulder is a live lane with occasional refuges - are inherently unsafe and dangerous and should be abandoned.

"The relevant test for us is whether someone who breaks down on this stretch of the motorway, where there is no hard shoulder, would have had a better chance of escaping death or injury had there still been a hard shoulder - and the coroner's verdict makes it clear that the answer to that question is - Yes."

The letter follows the findings of a coroner, David Urpeth, into the death of two men on the motorway, which he concluded was caused by there being no hard shoulder.

Highways England could also be charged with manslaughter following the death of a 62-year-old woman, Nargis Begum on a stretch of smart motorway, when another vehicle collided with her husband's Nissan Qashqai, which had broken down. 

Almost 40 people have been killed on smart motorways in the last five years, a BBC Panorama investigation revealed.

A recent survey by Venson Automotive Solutions, found that drivers support smart motorways, with 56% agreeing that they are necessary to help improve road safety and ease congestion.

Half responded saying they see the benefits for congestion levels and a quarter expect smart motorways to ease emissions.

However, one in ten admitted they didn’t know what a smart motorway is, highlighting the need for driver education.

Whilst the majority said they support the introduction of smart motorways, 35% of respondents to the Venson survey disagree, citing safety concerns as the main reason; 38% said they would not feel safe in case of a breakdown and being unable to reach an Emergency Refuge Area, 34% believe it unsafe to use the hard shoulder as a running lane in peak times.

Alison Bell, marketing director at Venson Automotive Solutions, said: “Private motorists and company car and van drivers need to familiarise themselves with the dos and don’ts.

“Businesses also have a duty of care to ensure their drivers know the rules of smart motorways and use them appropriately and safely.

“Every driver must understand what to do in the event of a breakdown or emergency, take notice of the red X above a closed lane, stick to the variable speed limit and keep left as much as possible unless overtaking.”

Following a review commissioned by the transport secretary last year, the Government introduced a series of measures to help improve the safety of smart motorways.

Analysis commissioned by the transport secretary reportedly found that "in most ways", smart motorways are as safe as, or safer than, conventional ones.

There was also an admission that some risks are higher than on conventional motorways, for example the risk of a collision between a moving and stationary vehicle.

The £1.5 billion investment in smart motorways, announced in 2015, has already seen major stretches built including over 100 miles of all lanes running (ALR) smart motorway sections on some of the UK’s busiest routes.

Read the PPC's full letter on the South Yorkshire police and crime commissioner website.

Watch now: Connecting Policy To Solutions Virtual Conference 2021

Smart Transport Conference returned on June 8th & 9th, to facilitate pivotal discussions on the future of transport. 

The UK’s most senior public and private sector transport leaders discussed the impact of Covid-19, achieving the Government’s decarbonisation ambitions, the need for more efficient living and better health, and much more.

Kwasi Kwarteng, secretary of state at the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), who spoke on BEIS's approach to decarbonising transport, particularly the electrification of the vehicle industry. Watch his presentation below:


Comment as guest

Login  /  Register


  • Brian - 12/01/2022 19:50

    Ban running lanes as this is non sensible . People should not have to die just to get more vehicles on the roads . When a new lane is created the verge along side should be dug back to create a safe area all along the road.

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register

Related content

Office Address
  • Smart Transport
    Media House
    Lynch Wood
    PE2 6EA
Join the community
  • Smart Transport is the UK's most important brand to bring together senior public policy makers and influential private sector leaders to showcase real-time solutions aligned to government policy.
  • Find out more
  • Insight


Welcome to Smart Transport

Welcome to the Smart Transport website, keeping you up-to-date with the latest news, insight and reports from policymakers and thought leaders.

The Smart Transport brand connects policy to solutions by bringing national government and local authority policymakers together with private sector organisations.

Contact Lindsay Greatbatch for more information.

© Bauer Consumer Media Ltd
Media House, Lynch Wood, Peterborough, PE2 6EA - Registered number 01176085 IPSO regulated logo


Smart Transport members

Smart Transport board members


Please note:
By submitting any material to us you are confirming that the material is your own original work or that you have permission from the copyright owner to use the material and to authorise Bauer Consumer Media to use it as described in this paragraph. You also promise that you have permission from anyone featured or
referred to in the submitted material to it being used by Bauer Consumer Media. If Bauer Consumer Media receives a claim from a copyright owner or a person
featured in any material you have sent us, we will inform that person that you have granted us permission to use the relevant material and you will be responsible for paying any amounts due to the copyright owner or featured person and/or for reimbursing Bauer Consumer Media for any losses it has suffered as a result.